Do you need to rent a car in Madeira?+
For a week-long trip combining hikes, viewpoints and villages, yes: a car remains the simplest and cheapest way to get around. For a short stay based entirely in Funchal, it's unnecessary. A well-planned trip can also use a car for only part of the days.
Is it difficult to drive in Madeira?+
The roads are in excellent condition and the tunnels have removed most of the intimidating stretches. What comes as a surprise are the very steep slopes in the villages and hill starts. A small car, a gentle driving style and an automatic gearbox if you're unsure are enough to make the experience very comfortable.
Manual or automatic gearbox in Madeira?+
An automatic costs €10 to €20 more a day but genuinely improves comfort on the 20% slopes, especially around Câmara de Lobos, Curral das Freiras and the northern villages. For a driver not fully confident on hills, it's the most worthwhile extra of the trip.
How much does a week's car rental cost in Madeira?+
Expect around €150 to €220 a week outside high season for a city car with basic insurance, and more like €300 to €450 in July-August. You'll sometimes see teaser offers of €12 or €15 a day, but they almost always climb once insurance, an automatic gearbox or a second driver are added. Add fuel (€40 to €70) and, if your accommodation is in central Funchal, parking.
Can you visit Madeira without a car?+
Yes, provided you accept a different pace: public buses to the main towns, private transfers, guided day trips for the levadas and Pico do Arieiro. It's an itinerary in its own right, one I regularly build for travellers who would rather not drive.